Skip to main content

Critics at Large

Critics at Large
A weekly culture roundtable from The New Yorker’s critics.

Listen and subscribe: Apple | Spotify | Wherever You Listen

All Episodes

Late Night’s Last Laugh

The cancellation of “The Late Show with Stephen Colbert” raised eyebrows, but the genre is not what it was in Johnny Carson’s heyday. What does it still have to offer us?

“Eddington” and the American Berserk

Ari Aster’s new film attempts to capture the particular brain-breaking turmoil of May, 2020. Can it—or any work of art—measure up to the craziness of real life?

“Materialists,” “Too Much,” and the Modern Rom-Com

Romantic comedies tend to reflect their eras’ attitudes toward women and relationships. What do new works in the genre have to tell us about sex and love today?

The Diva Is Dead, Long Live the Diva

We’ve worshipped divinely talented but demanding women for centuries. In an era of careful language and online backlash, is there still room for the diva?

Why We Turn Grief Into Art

In dark times, many novelists, poets, and performers turn to their work to process and express what they’re feeling. What do these texts born of tragedy offer their audience?

Our Romance with Jane Austen

The author’s novels are critiques of Regency England’s high society. Why, two hundred and fifty years after her birth, does her work resonate so strongly with modern audiences?

“Mountainhead” and the Age of the Pathetic Billionaire

Extreme wealth has long been an obsession within American culture—but Jesse Armstrong’s new film reflects a sea change in the way we view the über-rich.

Lessons from “Sesame Street”

The long-running children’s show is one of the last remaining pieces of American monoculture. But after a half century of change, is “Sesame Street” still the same place we know and love?

The Grand Spectacle of Pope Week

Robert Francis Prevost’s election to the papacy has captivated audiences at the Vatican and online alike. How did the Pope become a pop-cultural symbol?

I Need a Critic: May, 2025, Edition

The hosts of Critics at Large issue recommendations on TV shows to watch while eating, how to ease the guilt of unread books, and texts to take the edge off of current events.

How “Sinners” Revives the Vampire

The myth of the vampire has been with us for centuries—and undergone some dramatic transformations along the way. What does its latest incarnation have to say?

War Movies: What Are They Good For?

“Warfare” reconstructs an ill-fated 2006 mission in Iraq from the memories of the Navy SEALs involved. Does this method bring us closer to the reality of combat?

“The Studio” Pokes Fun at Hollywood’s Existential Struggle

The new Apple TV+ show follows a bumbling studio executive who’s caught between making great movies and making marketable ones. The industry itself faces a similar challenge.

Gossip, Then and Now

For much of history, gossip has functioned as a regulating force—one with the power to burnish its subjects’ reputations or to cast them from society. Have new technologies changed the game?

Joe Rogan, Hasan Piker, and the Art of the Hang

New forms of media that invite intense parasociality are capturing the attention of young men. What does it portend for our politics?

Critics at Large Live: The Right to Get It Wrong

The hundred-year history of The New Yorker includes reviews that anointed now classic works—as well as some that feel wildly out of step today. But is going against the grain such a bad thing?

Our Modern Glut of Choice

A mind-boggling array of options defines nearly every aspect of our world today, including shopping, dating, and entertainment. Is such abundance making our lives better?

How “The Pitt” Diagnoses America’s Ills

Max’s new medical drama puts the daily grind of a resource-strapped E.R. on full display. At a time when Americans are angrier at the health-care system than ever, is the genre changing to meet the moment?

In “Severance,” the Gothic Double Lives On

The new season of the Apple TV+ show is the latest in a string of entertainments—including several Oscar nominees—that feature split personalities. Why is this nineteenth-century trope back in such force today?

The Staying Power of the “S.N.L.” Machine

The comedy institution has come a long way from its ragtag, countercultural roots. Fifty years on, is it still essential viewing?